Planetary Health Diet vs Mediterranean Diet

Total Rating
7.0
out of 10
8.6
out of 10
Metabolic Health
8
Balances plant-based nutrients with moderate animal products, improving insulin sensitivity and lipid profiles while reducing inflammation.
9
Strongly improves blood sugar, lipid profiles, and inflammation while maintaining metabolic flexibility.
Micronutrients
5
Provides adequate coverage for most micronutrients but risks deficiencies in B12, vitamin D, and iodine without fortified foods or supplements.
8
Provides adequate coverage of most essential micronutrients but may require attention to vitamin B12, D, and iron bioavailability in certain scenarios.
Nutrient Density
7
Balances diverse plant foods with sustainable animal products, offering moderate nutrient density per calorie but limited phytonutrient diversity compared to stricter plant-based diets.
9
Prioritizes diverse, minimally processed plant foods with high phytonutrient density and bioavailability.
Overall Health
8
Balances nutritional adequacy and disease prevention benefits with moderate flexibility, though potential nutrient gaps require mindful adherence.
9
Strongly supports long-term metabolic health, reduces chronic disease risk, and maintains nutritional adequacy without excessive restrictions.
Sustainability
7
Offers moderate flexibility and practicality but may face challenges with long-term adherence due to reduced animal product consumption and potential social/psychological barriers.
9
It offers high flexibility, accessibility, and long-term adherence potential with minimal psychological strain.
Lifestyle Fit
7
Offers moderate flexibility for social and travel scenarios but requires careful planning to balance plant-based and limited animal product consumption.
9
Offers high flexibility and social compatibility with minimal preparation demands.
Practicality
7
Offers balanced affordability and accessibility but requires moderate planning and preparation effort.
9
Offers a balanced mix of affordable, widely accessible ingredients with minimal preparation effort and adaptability to daily routines.
Appetite Control
7
Balances protein, fiber, and whole foods to support satiety but may lack strict evidence on long-term appetite suppression.
8
Balances protein, fiber, and healthy fats to support satiety and stable hunger without extreme restrictions.
Fat Quality
7
Emphasizes whole-food unsaturated fats but relies on ALA without sufficient EPA/DHA, limiting long-chain omega-3 benefits.
8
Prioritizes whole-food unsaturated fats and omega-3s from fish, but lacks strict optimization of omega-3 to omega-6 balance and saturated fat context.
Fiber Intake
9
Prioritizes diverse, nutrient-dense plant foods that meet fiber quantity and quality standards while supporting gut and metabolic health.
9
Provides diverse, high-quality fiber from whole foods, supporting gut health and metabolic stability.
Gut Health
8
Promotes diverse fiber intake and fermented foods, supporting microbiome diversity and digestive health with strong scientific evidence.
8
Significantly enhances gut microbiome diversity and supports metabolic and immune health through fiber-rich, fermented, and nutrient-dense foods.
Hormonal Support
7
Provides balanced macronutrients and fiber for hormone regulation but may lack specific micronutrients critical for hormonal function.
8
Balances macronutrients and micronutrients to support stable hormones, but may lack precision in specific sex hormone modulation.
Macro Balance
7
Provides adequate protein and healthy fats but may underdeliver on optimal protein-to-carb balance for specific performance goals.
8
Offers balanced macronutrient distribution with adaptable ratios and strong evidence for metabolic and cardiovascular health.
Protein Quality
6
Provides adequate but incomplete plant proteins with potential amino acid gaps and lower digestibility compared to animal sources.
7
Provides balanced protein sources with adequate amino acids but relies on plant-based proteins which may limit digestibility and leucine content compared to animal sources.
Taste
7
Offers moderate flavor variety and adaptability but may require effort to avoid blandness.
8
Offers rich, diverse flavors and adaptability, enhancing meal satisfaction and long-term adherence.
Body Composition
6
Provides moderate fat loss potential but risks lean mass loss due to lower protein intake compared to optimal levels for muscle preservation.
8
Effectively supports fat loss while preserving lean mass through balanced macronutrients and sustainable eating patterns.
Energy Balance
7
Offers moderate satiety through fiber and volume but lacks structured calorie control mechanisms for consistent energy management.
7
Supports satiety and flexibility but lacks structured calorie control mechanisms.
Lean Mass
6
Provides adequate protein but may struggle with optimal amino acid balance and energy density for sustained lean mass retention during calorie deficits.
6
Provides moderate protein adequacy but may struggle with lean mass retention during significant caloric deficits without careful planning.
Athletic Support
6
Provides adequate carbohydrates and hydration but may lack sufficient protein and energy density for high-intensity athletic demands.
7
Provides balanced macronutrients and micronutrients but may lack optimal timing strategies for high-intensity performance.
Weight Loss
7
Promotes sustainable calorie deficit through plant-forward foods but lacks robust long-term evidence for preferential fat loss over lean mass.
7
Promotes sustainable calorie deficit and fat loss with balanced macronutrients and long-term adherence potential.

To discover how we evaluate diets based on Overall Health, Nutrient Density, Practicality, Taste, and other critical parameters, Explore Our Comprehensive Ranking System and detailed methodology. This will help you make informed decisions tailored to your specific goals and needs.